"All Boy" is about a family, mother, father, and a precocious eleven-year old son, Harold, and housekeeper, Mrs. Norman, in which the father desires to come "out of the closet" and Harold wants to return to the closet in which Mrs. Norman put him while she watched her soap operas. The structure of this story is its strength, I think.
"All Boy" was first published in the New England Review and subsequently in The Best American Short Stories, 2010.
I like the story. No one is different at the end of the story, except that the father has admitted that he is gay and moves out. We see a family disintegrate which was already in trouble because Mr. Lundstrom, a banker, married a woman, which was against his nature. The story takes place in 1976 which is only referred to once concerning a Halloween party. I find Mr. Lundstrom particularly brave and honest given the time frame.
My favorite sentence about Harold: "He did not feel that he was being dishonest because he cared deeply about grammar and would have gone on using 'may' even without such incentives." It doesn't sound as funny isolated here but in the context of the story, it's hilarious and great.
Ostlund's web page
Ostlund reads "All Boy" on Vimeo
NPR, Richard Russo talks about "All Boy"
blog about Lori Ostlund
Short Review, Q&A with Ostlund
Short Stories All the Time
- Ann Graham
- ------I use this blog to keep track of the short stories I've read along with a few of my thoughts about point of view, theme, setting and voice. I include journal and author tags.
------I write short stories; they are not posted online but I have a creative writing prompt book for sale on both Amazon and iBookstore.
"Lemon Cookies," short story.
"Stories," flash fiction pieces.
"When," short story.
WRITING PROMPT BOOKS
READY, SET, GO WRITE! 1st edition available on the iBookstore
READY, SET, GO WRITE! 2nd edition on Amazon for the Kindle